PitchName
Buying domainsDomain valuation

.com vs .ai vs .io: Which Domain Extension Sells Best?

Which domain extension sells best for investors? We compare .com, .ai, .io and others using real expired-auction sales, and explain who buys each one.

PitchName Team6 min read
Domain extensions .com, .ai and .io compared side by side, with auction prices for each

Every domain investor eventually asks the same question: should I buy the .com, or is the .ai or .io version good enough? Startups love .ai and .io. Small businesses still want .com. And the extension you pick changes who will buy the name, how fast it sells, and how much it costs you to hold.

This guide compares the most popular extensions using real auction data, then explains who actually buys each one, so you can decide where to put your money.

What the auction data shows

We looked at every expired-domain auction sale recorded in PitchName's Sales History between October 27 and November 11, 2026, from GoDaddy and Dynadot expired auctions. That's about 22,600 sales. These are wholesale prices, what investors pay each other for expired names, not what end users pay. But they show clearly where investor money goes.

Extension Sales Average price Median price Sold for $100+ Highest sale
.com 19,731 $62 $5 9.0% $47,000
.org 1,463 $56 $6 9.9% $13,499
.net 1,071 $40 $6 6.1% $4,100
.co 213 $91 $1 16.4% $3,149
.io 114 $23 $1 8.8% $442
.app 31 $32 $8 3.2% $800
.ai 1 $198 $198 n/a $198

A few things stand out.

.com is the market

Almost nine out of ten sales were .com. There are simply far more .com names, far more buyers, and far more competition for the good ones. The highest sale in the whole period, $47,000, was a .com. If you want liquidity, meaning a name you can actually sell to another investor when you need to, .com is still the only extension with a deep market.

Most names sell for almost nothing

The median .com sold for $5. Half of all expired .com names that sold went for $5 or less. That's the reality of expired auctions: most names are worth roughly their renewal fee, and a small share are worth a lot. The average is pulled up by a handful of big sales.

.io and .co are thin markets

.io had only 114 sales in two weeks, with a median of $1 and a top sale of $442. .co did a little better at the top end, with 16% of sales above $100, but on only 213 sales. These extensions do sell, but there are far fewer investor buyers, which makes a quick resale much harder.

Almost no .ai at expired auctions

Only one .ai name sold in these auctions. That doesn't mean .ai names don't sell. It means good .ai names rarely end up in GoDaddy or Dynadot expired auctions: their owners renew them, or they're sold directly and on marketplaces like Atom, Afternic and Sedo. So the .ai market is mostly an end-user and aftermarket market, not an expired-auction one. That's worth knowing before you go looking for cheap .ai names at auction.

Who buys each extension

Auction prices tell you what investors pay. End-user sales are where the profit is, so the more useful question is: who will buy the name from you?

.com: everyone

Local businesses, established companies, ecommerce stores and anyone selling to the general public want .com. It's what customers type by default and what they trust. A plumber in Denver, a dentist in Phoenix or a roofing company in Miami will almost always want the .com, and many won't consider anything else.

If you're selling to small businesses, which is where outbound sales work best, .com is the clear choice.

.ai: AI startups and tech companies

.ai has become the standard for artificial intelligence startups, and short, meaningful .ai names can sell for real money to funded companies. But the buyer pool is narrow: AI startups, mostly in tech hubs. A local bakery doesn't want a .ai. Our Domain Idea Finder warns you about this when you search for local-market names on .ai.

.ai renewals are also expensive, usually far more per year than a .com, so holding a portfolio of .ai names costs much more while you wait for a buyer.

.io: developer tools and tech startups

.io is popular with developer tools, SaaS products and gaming. Like .ai, its buyers are mostly tech companies, and it also renews at a higher price than .com. Demand for .io has cooled as .ai took over as the trendy tech extension, which the thin auction market reflects.

.net and .org: second choices

.net is usually the fallback when the .com is taken, and it rarely commands strong prices on its own. .org has a clear audience, nonprofits, communities and associations, and it held up surprisingly well in the data, with a median and $100+ share close to .com.

.co: startups with a short budget

.co often appeals to startups that can't get the .com. It sells, but buyers are limited, and many people still mistype it as .com.

How to choose which extension to buy

Match the extension to the buyer

Before you buy, picture the business that will use the name. If it's a local service business, buy the .com or skip it. If it's an AI startup, a strong .ai can make sense. Our guide on how to value a domain name walks through this buyer-first approach.

Check if the .com is taken and used

A .ai or .io is much easier to sell when the matching .com is unused or for sale cheaply. If a real company already runs a business on the .com, the other extensions of that name are much weaker, and they can bring trademark trouble. Read the UDRP trap before buying another version of someone's brand.

Count the renewals

A $10-a-year .com held for five years costs about $50 to $60. A .ai can cost several times that over the same period. Since most names take years to sell, renewals often decide whether a name makes money. Our guide to tracking domain ROI shows how to work out the real cost.

Look at real sold prices, not asking prices

Asking prices on marketplaces tell you what sellers hope for. Sold prices tell you what the market pays. Always check comparable sales before you buy or set a price.

How PitchName helps you pick the right extension

  • Sales History: see what names containing your keyword sold for at expired auctions, with the average, median and highest price, for each extension.
  • AI Domain Rating: get a value range and the likely buyers for a name before you buy it.
  • Domain Search and Name ideas: check a name across many extensions at once and see which are available.
  • Domain Idea Finder warnings: get a heads-up when you search local-market names on .ai or similar tech extensions.
  • Buyer Finder: for local service names, list the businesses that could buy the .com from you.

The bottom line

For most domain investors, .com still sells best: it has by far the biggest market, the most buyers and the highest top-end prices. .ai can be very profitable, but only with a strong name and a tech buyer in mind, and at a much higher holding cost. .io and .co sell in thin markets, so buy them only with a clear buyer in view. Whatever you buy, start with the business that will use the name, and check real sold prices before you pay. If you're just starting, read our domain flipping guide for beginners.

Data: expired-domain auction sales recorded in PitchName's Sales History, October 27 to November 11, 2026. Prices are wholesale auction prices in US dollars.

Try PitchName free.

All articles